LKV Realty
Logo
5818 E New York Street photo 1
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 2
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 3
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 4
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 5
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 6
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 7
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 8
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 9
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 10
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 11
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 12
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 13
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 14
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 15
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 16
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 17
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 18
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 19
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 20
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 21
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 22
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 23
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 24
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 25
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 26
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 27
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 28
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 29
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 30
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 31
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 32
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 33
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 34
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 35
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 36
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 37
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 38
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 39
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 40
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 41
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 42
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 43
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 44
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 45
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 46
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 47
Loading image5818 E New York Street photo 48
$185,000
$900Reward *
5818 E New York Street, Indianapolis, IN 46219Listing ID 22104506

5818 E New York Street, Indianapolis, IN 46219

Active
Charles M Cross Sub
Time on site: 80 days • Last updated: Jul 23, 2026
Property Type
Property Type
Residential Income
Property Sub Type
Property Sub Type
Duplex
Acres
Acres
0.17
Days on Site
Days on Site
33
Year Built
Year Built
1914
Garages
Garages
2
Parking
Parking
Detached

Welcome home to this charming historic gem in the heart of Irvington! Nestled on a tree-lined street, this classic home blends timeless character with everyday functionality. Featuring spacious living areas, original charm, and a generous lot, this property offers the perfect combination of warmth and opportunity. Enjoy hardwood floors, abundant natural light, and a layout ideal for both entertaining and daily living. While the detached garage and large backyard add convenience and privacy. Located just minutes from local shops, restaurants, parks, and downtown Indianapolis, this home delivers historic charm with an unbeatable location.

Property Information

Property Details

Location

Address
5818 E New York Street
County
Marion
City
Indianapolis
Zip Code
46219
Subdivision
Charles M Cross Sub
School District
Indianapolis Public Schools
MLS Area
4905 - Marion - Warren

Interior Features

Other Rooms

Laundry Features
Other

Building

Building Information

Year Built
1914
Construction
Aluminum Siding

Property Taxes

Tax Year
2024
Keller Williams Indy Metro NE, (317) 564-7100

Market Report for 46219

* The market data shown is based on available information from Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and/or public records. Data provided is for informational and educational purposes only and may not represent the full housing market. For more accurate information, consumers should consult a certified appraiser or licensed real estate agent.

*Average of $2,150 in rewards is calculated based on the purchase or sale of a home between $400,000 to $449,000. The median home price for all housing types is in the United States is $405,400 as of 2025 as reported by the National Association of Realtors® (NAR). The actual reward amount may vary depending on the purchase or sales price of the home. Please see the Lakeview Home Rewards program terms and conditions for more details. The National Association of Realtors® is a registered trademark of the National Association of Realtors®.

Source: MIBOR REALTOR® Association
MIBOR REALTOR® Association logo

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 17 Aug 2026, 06:24 AM UTC. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.

For corrections to this data please contact Brytecore MLS Support.

MBR30809 • MBR50844